Two
former executives of an advertising placement agency have been sentenced to federal
prison for stealing tens of millions of dollars from corporate clients such as
Sears, Roebuck & Co. and Universal
Studios, who paid their firm to place ads with broadcast media, including
ABC, NBC and Warner Brothers.
Thomas Edward
Rubin, the former chairman and CEO of Focus Media, Inc., a media
placement agency once located in Santa Monica, was sentenced late
Wednesday to 5½ years in prison. Rubin, 58, of Malibu, was
convicted at trial earlier this year of 25 felony counts, including
conspiracy, mail fraud, wire fraud, bankruptcy fraud and money
laundering.
Focus Media’s chief
financial officer, Thomas Patrick Sullivan, was sentenced yesterday
evening to 3½ years in prison. Sullivan, 65, of Westlake Village,
was found guilty by the same jury that convicted Rubin of 27 felony
counts.
Also yesterday, United
States District Judge Gary A. Feess sentenced the third defendant
in the case, attorney Geoffrey C. Mousseau, to 21 months in prison.
Mousseau, 46, of Glendale, was found guilty at trial of conspiring
with Rubin and Sullivan to commit bankruptcy fraud, concealing $500,000
in assets in a bankruptcy proceeding, perjury and other bankruptcy
fraud charges.
During the
4½-hour
sentencing hearing, Judge Feess said the actions of the defendants
were “deliberate and calculated.” While Focus Media was
a successful company, Rubin, whose salary of up to $1 million a year “wasn't
enough,” “killed the goose that laid the golden egg.” As
the three defendants pursued extensive litigation in civil and bankruptcy
court, according to Judge Feess, they “saw the legal process
as a means to effectuate their criminal conduct, not to seek justice.”
Focus Media’s
principal business was buying advertising time on television and
radio stations for clients, including Sears and Universal. For
more than a decade, Focus Media was a successful firm, but many
of its clients had left the firm by 1999. In addition to the loss
of its client base, Rubin had taken $16 million out of the company
in the form of shareholder loans between 1996 and 1999.
During a one-year
period that began in November 1999, Rubin and Sullivan conspired
to defraud Focus Media’s remaining corporate clients – Sears and
Universal – as well as the media outlets from which the firm
ordered advertising. The fraud consisted of simply taking the money
paid by its advertising clients to pay the media outlets and using
it for their own private purposes. Rubin and Sullivan collected funds
to pay for advertising for the last quarter of 1999, misappropriated
that money and never paid the media outlets who ran the ads. Even
after Sears and Universal obtained court orders prohibiting Rubin
and Sullivan from misappropriating their funds, the defendants continued
to do so, paying themselves, their lawyers and Focus Media employees.
During the
course of the year-long scheme, Focus Media received more than
$50 million from clients, but no more than $10 million was paid
to media outlets. Approximately $12 million out of the missing
$40 million was used to pay Rubin’s personal liabilities.
On October
6, 2000, Focus Media was forced into bankruptcy by three unpaid
media outlets, including ABC and NBC, which were hoping to preserve
whatever assets were left in the firm. A bankruptcy court judge
appointed a trustee to manage Focus Media’s finances and
preserve its assets, but Mousseau joined a conspiracy with Rubin
and Sullivan to pay Mousseau, and other law firms, with Focus Media
funds without the knowledge of the trustee. As part of the scheme,
Mousseau funneled approximately $500,000 into his attorney-client
trust fund to pay his legal fees and to fund payments to other
lawyers.
Judge Feess said yesterday
that he would order the defendants to pay restitution to victims.
The judge scheduled a hearing for January 29 to determine a specific
amount of restitution.
This case was investigated
jointly by the United States Postal Inspection Service and IRS Criminal
Investigation Division, which received assistance from the Federal
Bureau of Investigation. |